Thanks bdyman. I'll use your advice when I prep the molding for paint. I took a look on SEM's website and I think I found a close match. I'll include the color chart link below. Towards the bottom of the color chart there's a color called Med. Dk. Pewter (15813). Now I just have to find where I can buy it.
http://semproducts.com/images/Users/...0CC%202008.pdf