Dash Cap Color

[Mad Mike]

Fellas, I recently purchased a Coverlay dash cap from JC Whitney. I went with the dark grey option, but when I recieved it and installed it for dry fit, I found the color is a bit darker than the factory color on the dash, making it look sloppy. They also have a medium grey option on there site .
My question is, before I return the one I have to swap it for medium grey,
has anyone purchased a dash cap for a pewter interior Alero and was the medium grey more of a match than the dark grey color.
I know my other option is to paint it, but I'm having the same problem matching the color at my local auto and paint shops.
Ill post photos of the dash as soon as i get to my lap top. In the mean time, I have photos of the interior on the Showcase forum under "Just bought an Alero" from 7-22-13.
Thanks in advance